DO FAMILY OWNERS NEED CORPORATE GOVERNANCE?
DO FAMILY OWNERS NEED CORPORATE GOVERNANCE?
This website uses cookies in order to offer you the most relevant information. Please accept cookies for optimal performance. Find out more
×

Hawkamah Journal

Click Here For Full Journal

By Helmut Sihler

One expects the answer to this (rhetorical?) question in a publication designed to promote good Corporate Governance to be an unqualified “yes”. I do not believe this to be so. I will argue that the usefulness of “CG” for family owners is determined both by the definition of CG and the character of the family itself. I will draw on my long-year experience as a CEO in a family-owned company and several assignments as an advisor to entrepreneurial families.


Why did CG become a passionately discussed issue both in Europe and the USA in the last decades? Two causes can be identified: First and foremost the failure of large companies to sustain competitiveness, with ensuing share price erosion, and in some cases bankruptcy. And second the seemingly growing gap between shareholders’ interests and management actions. One might justifiably argue that the discussion in the US was more focussed on the first issue, while in Europe shareholders’ rights held center-stage.


Is better CG the solution to these perceived negative developments? Certainly not by itself. CG should be viewed as a tool which can be of great use in some, but not all corporate issues. CG is sometimes defined as a system of structures and procedures for preparing, taking, and controlling crucial decisions. This definition is not wrong in itself, but it leaves out the more important quality of attitude. We all know the basics of the US one-tier and the Central European two-tier architecture of Boards (by whatever name). They both have their advantages and their drawbacks, of course, but it would be hard to argue that one is better than the other. They both work as tools if they are handled right, or to put it differently, if the board leadership is up to its task.


Do family companies need CG? On the basis of what has been said before, the answer is “no” if it means taking a set of structures and procedures so to speak “off the shelf”. It is “yes” if CG is perceived as an attitude, a mental method if you will, to dealing with major interdisciplinary business problems. (Interdisciplinary: because these problems will usually be a mixture of factors like personnel, finance, marketing, production etc.)


Let me use as an example an entrepreneur who has built up a successful business. He has has not written any rules, and has not drawn up organisation charts. His greatest asset is his belief in himself. Does he need CG? His answer would be emphatically “no”. Simply put: he doesn’t need it, because he has it.


But situations change. Our entrepreneur might want to groom successors coming out of his family.  He might see the need of hiring a strong outside manager to handle the growing complexity of his business. He might set up daughter companies in foreign countries which in their management demand a different approach than in his home country. He might want to have a sounding board to hear comments on his business plans. In all of these and other instances he would have to ask himself: How did I do it, how do I do it?


It is not easy for successful entrepreneurs to reflect on their own style of management and on their basic attitude. In most cases, they will refuse to write down the result of their self-appraisal. But they must be willing to share their thoughts and experiences. Only then will others be able to make the greatest possible input, be they family members or outsiders. Therefore the most important first step in such times of change for any family-controlled company is to take a sober look at itself. It must identify its strengths and its weaknesses. But entrepreneurs (and their families) rarely want to take an objective look at themselves. There is always the fear of family frictions tending to be uncontrollable.


Qualified outsiders can be an important if not indispensable help in this process. They can ask the right questions, they have no personal interests beyond the task at hand, they help in formulating the results, they are not seen as serving their personal interests. They should be impartial catalysts. The outcome of this self-appraisal is not determined by the pre-conceived notions of such mediators. They would not be the right people if they pushed for any standard solution.


What would be the results of such an exercise? The nature of the business would be clearly defined and with it the strategic issues which will determine its future. The entrepreneur who had initiated such a process would have a better idea of the qualities and the shortcomings of his cooperators. He would be able to start a clearly defined initiation program for his children to ensure their qualification as potential successors. And, of course, he would see where a more formal CG could be a help and not a hindrance. But in any case it would be strictly tailored to his personal intentions and the nature of the expected developments.


Experience shows that formalized CG in public companies does not function well without a large dose of informality. A Chairman and a CEO do not cooperate only on the basis of their “job descriptions”; they must go far beyond that in establishing a working relationship. For family companies the reverse is true: Informality alone will not suffice. There must be a modicum of rules for the sharing of information and for coming to decisions. The names of such groupings are secondary. They can be called Advisory or Shareholders’ Committees or Boards. But they must be tailored to the needs and intentions of the entrepreneur and other family owners; they must ensure for their members a set of informations and for defined areas a share in decision making. Only then will they develop the right “attitude”: to help but not to meddle.

Testimonials

  • "A journey full of knowledge, experience and professionalism . I have learned a lot and definitely enjoyed the time I spent with my colleagues."

    Ibtihal Al-Shamali- Director of Corporate Governance- Capital Market Authority of Kuwait

  • The breakfast meetings organised by Hawkamah provide attendees with a great opportunity to meet with peers from leading organisations and exchange ideas on current issues and challenges. A strong panel of industry experts discussing the challenges from different perspectives on ‘How to get the board more engaged’ was most insightful and engaging with enthusiastic audience participation especially in matters regarding diversity and quality of information that is  presented to the board for effective decision making. I look forward to more such events that are organised by Hawkamah

    Sunil Edwards- Group Head of Internal Audit  - Bank of Sharjah

  • The power breakfast on board engagement organized by Hawkamah in collaboration with Diligent was a successful event, very insightful and informative and well organized

    Mostafa Ibrahim Abdeltawab - Tax Agent & Consultant  - Skylines Tax Consultancy

  • There is absolutely no doubt that Hawkamah – as always – has done unmatchable effort in producing its most recent valuable report in association with Diligent about Board Best Practices in the MENA. The discussions that took place in the “Power Breakfast” was so important and insightful; the influx of questions by the quality participants and the valuable answers of the quality panelists is a clear proof of Hawkamah continued success in such events. 

    Yasser Al Dabach – Board Secretary – Ghobash Trading & Investment Group

  • The technical knowledge, insights, case studies and learning provided by the ‘Director Development Program’ are very useful and effective in framing the strategic planning, implementation and delivery phases of growth plans in the difficult economic and geo-political times that we are operating in.

    Hisham Dimashki – CEO - BAP LLC – (associated with GM Trading Companies - Washington DC)

  • The certified Board Secretaries Workshop provided by Hawkamah and Dubai Financial Market is an essential course for learning corporate governance, scope and responsibilities of the board secretary and understanding the governance and disclosure requirements of the Dubai Financial Market and the Securities and Commodities Authority. It is a practical course which combined recent best practices and key learning lessons. I would highly recommend it for people involved in corporate governance and in particular in a listed company.

    Omran Al Zamani - Senior Legal Counsel - Dana Gas PJSC

  • Great program! Very well done and very useful information delivered in an excellent manner. The workshop was very inspirational, energizing, bringing lots of ideas, with both substantial and in-depth knowledge together with case studies. Well-balanced composition of participants, which contributed to interesting and focused discussions and exchanges. I would highly recommend it to anyone that is interested in improving their proficiency and core competencies.

    Hassan Murad Agha - Group Head of Compliance & Internal Control - Gulf General Investment Co. (PSC)

  • All companies should promote their boards, executive managers or staffs who have board responsibilities for subsidiary companies to attend corporate governance training. Hawkamah provides the ability for people and companies in the GCC to upskill in the area of corporate governance and directorship through a comprehensive programme teaching international best practice which has been tailored to regional specific governance issues.

    Alastair Mulligan - VP Asset Management - National Central Cooling Company PJSC (TABREED)

  • I am truly honored to attain this certification and I recommend the Compliance Heads of all DFM listed companies to participate and achieve this certification.

    Nabeel Mirza - Senior Director & MLRO - Compliance - GFH Financial Group B.S.C.

  • The workshop has added a level of professionalism to my practice. It addressed and discussed  the right concepts to promote better governance and effective support for business in line with rules and procedures.

    Osama Issaq Al Haj - Head of Legal & Board Secretary - Dubai Islamic Bank

Latest tweets

@Hawkamah
«الشؤون الإسلامية» تنظم ورشة عمل عن «الحوكمة» albayan.ae/across-the-uae…
twitter
@Hawkamah
89 representatives. 44 countries. 2020 Central Bank Governance Forum. pic.twitter.c...om/sWSeRulhwS
twitter

Partners