MUTUALS – CAN WE LEARN FROM THEM?
MUTUALS – CAN WE LEARN FROM THEM?
This website uses cookies in order to offer you the most relevant information. Please accept cookies for optimal performance. Find out more
×

Hawkamah Journal

Click Here for the Full Journal

By Peter Montagnon


A mutual structure – where an enterprise is owned either by its employees or its customers – is a relatively rare choice for regional enterprises. Family businesses will have little reason to convert, and the advantages for a growing business in need of capital are not obvious. Mutuals are relatively rare, too, in the US and Europe, but that does not mean we cannot learn from them. Indeed the concept became fashionable for a while in the wake of the banking crisis because mutuals appeared positioned to serve society better than the greedy and ultimately toxic banks.


The theoretical advantages are obvious. An enterprise that is owned by its customers is likely to give them better service. It will be more trustworthy and less likely to cheat them. The cooperative movement in the UK, which was started by the Rochdale Pioneers Society was a reaction to the habit of privately owned food retailers of adulterating food to make it cheaper, for example by adding things like sawdust into bread. One of its long-standing principles is that its customer members receive a share of the profits.


Similarly, a company owned by its employees is more likely to have a well-motivated workforce with high productivity and good service that will secure the franchise.


For many mutuals, the structure of their operations looks like the key to success. VanCity Services is an innovative financial services company in Vancouver, Canada, with assets of C$17.5bn. Founded in 1946, it has had a major impact on its local community. Among its achievements are that it was the first financial institution in Canada to offer a daily interest savings account, calculating interest on a daily basis and created the country’s first socially responsible mutual fund. Its board is elected by its membership which numbers over 400,000, and the company seeks to abide by a clear set of values and commitments on which it consulted with members, staff and community leaders.


Yet there are also drawbacks. The board has come under criticism for its practice of recommending new members for election. On the one hand this is designed to ensure it has a well qualified board. On the other, critics say the process has become undemocratic and can lead to entrenchments of the existing board and management. According to one of its critics, member Mark Latham, the risk with cooperatives is that their power structure can tend towards being an oligopoly.


Another problem is that mutuals cannot easily raise additional capital when they want to expand. Since there is no room for outside shareholders in their structure, they cannot issue new equity. They may be able to raise money in the long-term debt markets, but this is not going to provide a capital cushion against loss, which can be particularly problematic in the financial sector.


Of course, the answer may be that mutuals need to keep a close eye on long-term cash generation so that they build up a cushion of home-grown capital. But this may not always be easy if the customers who own it are more interested in squeezing profit margins so that they get a more favourable deal on their purchases.


Mutuals therefore need strong boards able to develop a clear commercial strategy and manage risk. But, as the Vancity experience shows, it is not always easy to select the right people and ensure that they are accountable. How can a body with several hundred thousand customer owners pick an effective board, and how can the board account to them for their actions?


The UK Cooperative Society hit trouble a couple of years ago because its bank ran up large losses after buying a failing mortgage lender. The organisation was shaken to its very core and Lord (Paul) Myners, a former investor and government minister and a noted expert on governance, was brought in to sort out its governance. He found the board was dysfunctional. It lacked expertise. Many directors had no idea about their organisation’s return on capital. They were appointed through a complex process which was very political and did not reflect merit.


In short the board was not fit for its core purpose of overseeing strategy and risk and making sure the organisation was accountable. Moreover the organisation was highly resistant to reform, and its bank meanwhile has had to accept outside capital in order to stay solvent, although the new investors have showed themselves determined to maintain its ethical ethos.


So what are the lessons from the mutual experience. First, a strong customer focus and a motivated workforce are important ingredients for a successful business. Of course, these can exist outside a mutual structure but management and owners may have to work a bit harder to deliver. Second, what matters for success are access to capital and governance arrangements which favour robust oversight and decision-making and accountability.


These are where mutuals are vulnerable, but the requirements are universal ones, applying also to listed companies with a dispersed ownership base and to family businesses. Regional companies may not want to become mutuals, but they can learn from them just the same.

Testimonials

  • "We extend our thanks and appreciation to Hawkamah institute for its cooperation and the effectiveness of the Director Development Program"

    Saeed Al Kaabi - Abu Dhabi Monitoring and Controlling Centre(ADMCC)

  • "The Director Development Program was very rich in useful information and added a lot to us, and the trainers’ experience, skills and capabilities had positive impact on delivering the information to us in a direct and clear manner"

    Hamad Al - Tamimi - Osool Asset Management

  • The corporate Governance in all type of entities adds morality and ensures implementation of the best practices to fulfill the responsibilities of those entities and to ensure the rights of all parties involved, especially those who have no authority to participate in the decision-making cycle.

    Hawkamah institute contributed to enrich the knowledge of these responsibilities and the role of governance for the success of institutional work in accordance with principles that establish values and ethics.

    Ajman Municipality

  • '‘Excellent, well delivered, informative program presented by well-seasoned trainers. The training program has helped transform and empower the Board’s vision and focus our minds on the relevant issues at hand. We sincerely thank you for the training sessions which helped broaden our perspective and decision making processes. We strongly recommend this training to elevate directors to the next level".

    Bank of Maldives

  • "I would like to thank Hawkamah for the ESG Reporting training , I found the two days ESG Reporting training very informative and helpful and I have definitely received some tools that I will use in my work"

    Rania Zaatari - Head of Makassed Communal Healthcare Bureau

  • "The DDP provides a solid foundation of corporate governance for existing and aspiring directors."

    David Haglund - Senior Executive Director and Portfolio Manager of the Templeton Frontier and MENA Market strategies

  • “Thank you so much for sharing such insightful webinar. It was great and valuable to all participate”

    Shady Rashed - Senior Economic Researcher at The Ministry of International Cooperation of Egypt

  • “Good session and very well organized on the webinar about How to buffer and lessen the impact of the novel Covid – 19, to maintain business sustainability with Hawkamah - AUB / Makhzoumi” 

    Bilal Hamade - Executive Advisor

  • "One of the best webinars I attended. Well done OSB Makhzoumi and Hawkamah”

    Fida Kanaan – Director – Executive education  OSB AUB

  • "A journey full of knowledge, experience and professionalism . I have learned a lot and definitely enjoyed the time I spent with my colleagues."

    Ibtihal Al-Shamali- Director of Corporate Governance- Capital Market Authority of Kuwait

Latest tweets

@Hawkamah
The Hawkamah Institute for Corporate Governance is proud to announce joining @dubaichamber as a Gold Sponsor for Ha… twitter.com/i/web/status/1…
twitter

Videos

Partners